General Topics

Ovadia Yosef Z”L

image_pdfimage_print

As a young man finding my way forward in the world of Torah study, I was completely bowled over by the genius of Rav Ovadia Yosef, who died this week. In all the contemporary rabbinic responsas I had read, nothing came near to the phenomenal breadth of his learning, his marshaling of sources, and above all his tolerant, often lenient conclusions.

The great Ashkenazi contemporary authorities I was studying almost invariably came to strict, restrictive conclusions. There was an almost undeclared agenda to constantly raise the bar rather than lower it. And they completely ignored the more recent great Sephardi authorities. It was almost as if they thought Sephardi scholarship ended with Maimonides.

From the moment I picked up the early volumes of his magisterial response, “Yabia Omer”, in 1957 I was completely won over by Rav Yosef‘s different approach. He brought the widest range of sources. He weighed the body of opinion and allowed the pure law to speak for itself, and most importantly of all, where he could he would find a lenient resolution. It was as if a new, younger, brilliant Chief Justice was suddenly appointed to the Supreme Court, stood head and shoulders above the other justices, and promised to sweep away all the cobwebs and vested interests. Having such a wider vision, he knew the range of options that went well beyond the conventional wisdom.

He was a product of the East. The Sephardi world was very different than the negative, cramped, inward-looking approach of Eastern Europe. Rav Yosef was brought up under Islam, where tensions were more political than religious. On many theological fundamentals Judaism and Islam agreed. Whereas under Christianity the bitterness of the Jewish experience, as well as the theological differences, created a far more negative approach to the world around them. True, the Shia mullahs were just as oppressive as Dominican friars, but under much of Islam Jews lived at peace and in cultural symbiosis.

The Sephardi world had no Reform movement. In Ashkenaz the rabbis were constantly fighting an internal schism. Their response was to tighten up, and if you didn’t like it you could jolly well go and join Reform or some other breakaway. Since the Sephardi world had no Reform, their rabbis had to deal with the full range of Jewish behavior, and their communities embraced the most lapsed as well as the strictest. Their halachic decisions had to take note of the full range of the faithful, not just the most pious.

And thirdly the Sephardi world seemed much more in sympathy with the poor, and therefore more lenient and less financially demanding. You could not ask a penniless family to have two dishwashers!

The downside of the Sephardi world, as much as of the poor Ashkenazi, was the superstitious belief in wonder, miracle rabbis, and Kabbalists. Rav Yosef bravely and courageously had no sympathy for religious hucksters and snake oil salesmen. Of all the Ashkenazi halachic masters, I dare to say only the late Rav Moshe Feinstein was his equal.

Rav Yosef was a powerful advocate and campaigner for Sephardi rights. In his early editions of “Yabia Omer” he railed against young Sephardi yeshiva students aping the Ashkenazi rabbis in dress and attitude. He insisted that the different Sephardi approach to Torah study be given equal standing in a world that, sadly, tended to look down on Eastern culture and still to this day too often discriminates against Sephardim.

This led him to form the Shas party in 1984. For years he was a voice in the wilderness. At last Shas gave him the power and the platform, although he had to battle major Ashkenazi authorities like Rav Shach, which ultimately led to an acrimonious split.

This was the moment that I lost my innocent reverence of the great man. I had been disappointed when in his term as Chief Rabbi he engaged in unseemly rivalry with his Ashkenazi colleagues. I put this down to the “Kinat Sofrim”, the Talmud’s phrase for the competition between intellectual giants. But party politics was another matter. I have always detested religious politics. Much of the good that Shas did, as a social movement, was undermined by the bargaining, haggling, and corruption that inevitably characterizes the world of politics. Of course religion is concerned with every aspect of human life. And I believe religious people should, as individuals, be involved in the political process. But when a party devoted specifically to religious issues enters the fray it invariably, regardless of the religion or the denomination, falls to the worst of political shenanigans. And so it has been with Shas, now divided into warring factions.

There was another aspect to this. Politics requires the sound-bite, the crowd-pleasing demagoguery, and Rav Yosef allowed himself, as he grew older and feebler, to be used. As indeed have too many venerable religious leaders. He came out with insulting, banal generalizations about non-Jews and about Jews he disagreed with, comments he would never have made in his early days. It is a feature, again, of Israeli life to argue via humiliation and disrespect instead of ideas. Was it senility, or being surrounded by fixers and middlemen in his old age? Whatever, it remains a shadow on his legacy.

He strongly believed in the ideal of Jewish-Arab coexistence and argued halachically in favor of “Land of Peace”. Being a child of the Muslim world he, more than any other contemporary Israeli rabbi, met and got on with Arab clerics and politicians. He also understood the Arab mentality and antagonisms of the Arab Street and was skeptical about the Arab will to come to terms.

What is his legacy? There are those who say he capitulated to Charedi Ashkenazi orthodoxy in the end. It is true his sons and the Shas leadership now ape the Ashkenazi rabbis. Still he was a polymath like no other in the field of Jewish jurisprudence, an absolute giant. There is no one now in the field to compare with him. As far as his impact on the Jewish State is concerned, he helped raise Sephardi pride. But the struggle goes on. To this day, unbelievably, there is discrimination in Charedi Israel against Sephardim. There is still an excessive preoccupation with minute strictness in Jewish law and sadly political life in Israel is as disappointing today as when he entered the field hoping to change it.

There is no one who comes near to wearing his mantle. No Elisha to his Elijah. The Chariot of Israel has departed.
========

RIGHT OR RIGHT
by Jeremy Rosen

I have written a short book setting out my attitude to religion in general and Judaism in particular. It is an argument for a thinking, analytical religion as opposed to fundamentalism and for the combination of rationalism with a spiritual existential approach to Judaism. It is called Right or Right: How to reconcile rationality with religion and you can find it on Amazon and Kindle.

13 thoughts on “Ovadia Yosef Z”L

  1. Thank you for writing this Rabbi; it is beautiful by the way. I was only familiar with the R. Ovadia Yosef, zt'l, of late. And the internet being what it is, there is no shortage of opinions from either extreme. In spite of whatever shortcomings he may have had, this man was learned in Torah and most importantly a fellow Jew. It tears me up inside both to see my fellow Jews behaving badly and speaking badly of each other. So again, thank you for this!

  2. Hi again Rabbi Rosen, will be downloading the book to my Kindle tonight. On the other part of your latest post, I read a fair bit about the passing of Rav Yosef and the events around it in Israel. At the same time a lovely Aunt of my wife died, she was the same age and a retired nurse.
    I suppose what puzzled me most was the difference in funeral customs, the ceremony for the Rav was a huge outpouring of grief. The ceremony for the retired nurse was a celebration of a life well lived. I know both did their best and I'm pretty sure both are in the same place.
    Why the difference ?

  3. The death of a scholar is considered in a figurative way to resemble the death of Torah or some national catastrophe like the loss of the Temple in which everyone shares. So the whole of the Torah community feeling this loss, tries to make the funeral a national display rather than one of private mourning.
    J

  4. Hi Rabbi Rosen,
    I've been reading your blog for years and have been really enjoying it. Sadly, I left Manhattan (and thusly the Persian Congregation) before you joined as their rabbi.
    I really appreciate your perspective on the issues you write on, and share your sentiments for the most part. What you wrote for Rabbi Yosef is no exception. I've thought and said the same of him for years and your post is spot on.
    He was a compassionate voice in the religious world. A voice which cared about, and wanted to resolve issues for, agunot/questionable almanot, mamzerim, and Ethiopian immigrants. It's a shame that his later legacy was tarnished by racism, that type of ignorant remarks which is typical of Israeli argumentation, and even just being associated with people like Deri.
    Unfortunately, I don't think Yosef's sons are interested in continuing their father's older ways

  5. Good to hear from you and thank you for the compliment.
    You are missed at this end but hopefully you are in a good plce elsewhere!
    Sadly I think you're right and OY zl's sons are not going to continue his legacy. Though I am a great admirer of his daughter who has founded a serious educational institution!!!

  6. I'm living in Chicago these days and I'm very happy here, but I definitely miss New York and the Persian Congregation. It's been over 6 years since I have moved.

    I do recall reading something about his daughter a little while back. I forget where exactly, but I remember thinking that this was a stark departure from her brothers. I think she was attacking the haredi treatment of women as being anti-halakhah, or something in that vein

  7. May I ask wht you do in Chicago? Is there a big Sephardi community?

    As for OY's daughter: Her name is Aina Bar Shalom and shes a doughty fighter for women's education and rights and still Orthodox!!!

  8. I'll respond to with the more personal stuff in email.

    I really respect it when orthodox figures can be pluralistic and open minded. The rabbi in the main orthodox congregation in Chicago, Asher Lopatin, has just moved to NY for a position at Chovevei Torah. His mindset seems similar to yours. I wouldn't be surprised if you are familiar with him.

Leave a Reply