General Topics

Impeachment

image_pdfimage_print

In 1599, a group of London merchants got together to petition Queen Elizabeth 1st to grant a charter to “trade on wares, jewels or merchandise in the East Indies.” A year later, it was granted. And so began the life of the East India Company (EIC). 

Over time, and from very inauspicious beginnings as a private company, it came to rule and exploit the whole of the Indian subcontinent. Until India’s independence in 1947. After building a series of trading posts and forts, it negotiated for trading rights with the different ethnic and religious rulers of India, the Muslim Mughals in the North and Bengal, the Hindu Marathas in the West and Tipu in the south. Then it sent its representatives to spread out, trade, bully and insult them to make huge fortunes which make our High-tech billionaires look puny.  Eventually, after several setbacks, the EIC fought them with its private armies, modern armaments, and military techniques. Eventually, it neutralized the French competition by practicing the old Roman policy of divide and rule.

Enter Warren Hastings. He was a career administrator and an honest, cultured and moral man. His mother had died in childbirth in 1732. His father disappeared on a voyage to the West Indies. Warren ended up in an orphanage from which an uncle rescued him and sent him to one of the best schools in England. There, he excelled, and the uncle got him a job in the EIC. Hastings rose up the ranks. He was sent to India. Captured in the battle of Kazimbazar he used his imprisonment to learn the language and the culture of his captors and in due course became governor of Murshidabad.

In 1760, Warren Hastings wrote to London that “this country lies groaning under the anarchy. Laws have no power of sanction, morals are corrupt to the ultimate degree…the oppressions committed under the sanction of the English name is beyond imagination.”

In London, Parliament was becoming concerned about the autonomy of the EIC and took a firmer interest in its activities. Warren Hastings was appointed Governor-General in 1773. He tried to balance the commercial interests of the EIC with humanitarian ones and to impose discipline and standards on the organization, its employees and the thousands of fortune-hunting agents spread out across the continent. But with limited success.

The EIC ‘s board like many companies was a hotbed of rivalries and cliques. It was split between those who wanted profits no matter the cost and those who also demanded standards of good governance and ethics. Hastings saw his mission as “draining the swamp.”  Inevitably, he made enemies both in India and back in London.

In 1774, a triumvirate of inspectors went out to India to inspect the situation. Amongst them was Philip Francis – the man who became Warren Hastings’s nemesis. He had an old grudge against Hastings. He hated him with a passion and set out to undermine him. He denounced him to London. Eventually, they fought a duel in which Hastings bullet seriously wounded Francis. Hastings aided Francis’s recovery and enabled him to return home in 1782. There, Francis, instead of being grateful grew more vindictive and embarked on a campaign to blacken the reputation of Hastings and eventually succeeded in getting him impeached by Parliament in 1788.

The impeachment was heavily politicized and set the leadership of the Whigs and the Tories, the two main parties, against each other. Each side produced champions who spoke to their constituencies and the gallery.  It was an amazing circus in which seats to the hearings changed hands for large sums of money (the equivalent of $10,000 in modern currency). Amongst the orators were Richard Brinsley Sheridan (the great playwright), Edmund Burke (the Whig Anglo-Irish political thinker regarded as the founder of modern conservatism) and  Charles James Fox (the radical supporter of the French Revolution). They emphasized issues of what today we call “human rights”. In reality, it was the EIC the institution and its investors who were under attack. 

The case dragged on for seven years. Warren Hastings was finally and completely vindicated in 1795. The proceedings led to the complete restructuring of the EIC’s role in India.  Control of EIC was eventually ceded to the Government. Not that they were so much better. The record of British Imperial rule over India is one of brutality, racism and arrogance.

An interesting footnote is that the man sent out after Hastings to impose order and to defeat the Indian forces threatening to destroy the British presence in India was none other than Charles Cornwallis – the British General who had surrendered the Thirteen Colonies to George Washington. He was regarded as strong and honest. Having failed once, he learnt his lesson. He brought about a permanent settlement and defeated Tipu Sultan in the Third Anglo Mysore War (with the help of Colonel Arthur Wellesley who later became the Duke of Wellington for defeating Napoleon). If you are interested in history, I recommend The Anarchy, the Relentless Rise of the East India Company by William Dalrymple.

I am reminded of all this by what is happening in the United States today. An impeachment process where major governmental challenges are ignored and the whole proceeding reeks of personal vendetta. Then as now, politicians are not covering themselves with glory.

There is, of course, no comparison between Hastings and Trump as individuals. But there are similarities in the animus, theatricality and political grandstanding. It will be interesting to see how this one ends!

5 thoughts on “Impeachment

  1. The word “relentless” seems most apposite with regard to Francis. Its return to politics at what, historically, should be a time of enlightenment, has not only touched Trump. One only has to look at what is going on in British politics vis a vis Brexit, elections, antisemitism etc. etc. to see that nothing ever changes. Relentless is the word.
    Shabbat Shalom, Jeremy and many thanks for another excellent column.

  2. A lot of this is liberal BS Dr Rosen.

    The British Empire was a great blessing to those evil heathens. And India benefited so greatly as a country.
    (Even my Hindu employees tell me this!) We were the first contact they’d ever had with the values of the Hebrew Bible & the great G-d.

    Dr Rosen you should know & defend this truth!

    1. Yes you are right, I have heard this said and written about. It reminds me of the part of Monty Python’s life of Brian where John Cleese asks ” What have the Romans ever done for us.” The record of British Imperialism has some good points. The Mughals and the others were indeed often corrupt, self serving and self-defeating. But all conquered people tend to think they should be allowed to make their own mistakes.

  3. A very interesting post. I’m not following what’s going on in the US but the history of British India is, as Frederic Stevens says above, an example of how accounts of history change to reflect the current agenda. I know that the British exploited and abused the Indians and other colonials, and I hesitate to write ‘but’ here, it has become fashionable to deride all aspects of the British Empire and to be thoroughly ashamed of its very existence. Historical truth needs to acknowledge the good as well as the bad and the ugly. (This is not a criticism of this post, just an observation following FS’s comment.)

  4. I do agree with FS’s comments that there was some good. Imposing an overall administration etc and there are always two sides. But as a matter of interest here are two comments I have received in response to my piece.

    1. Our entire family were born in Bombay, Calcutta, and Poona – following anti-semitism in Baghdad, Basra and Spain. Then in the mid 1950’s the majority emigrated to Australia Britain and Israel.
    Yes – we know the British were indeed were a very cruel race.

    2. In South India the students that come to our schools say that their family tales are that until 300 years ago they were all very educated Until the Brits came. They stoped all education so they can have them all as labourers

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.